Answer: C (magnesium chloride). Salt P must be preparable by both routes. The acid + metal route needs a metal above hydrogen in the reactivity series but not dangerously reactive. The acid + insoluble carbonate route needs an insoluble carbonate (so excess can be filtered off) that gives a soluble salt able to crystallise from the filtrate.
Magnesium fits both: Mg + 2HCl → MgCl₂ + H₂, and MgCO₃ (insoluble) + 2HCl → MgCl₂ + H₂O + CO₂; magnesium chloride is soluble.
Copper is below hydrogen, so it does not react with dilute acid. Lead(II) sulfate is insoluble, so it cannot crystallise from solution. Sodium is far too reactive for the metal + acid method, and sodium carbonate is soluble, not insoluble.
Every O Level Pure Chemistry TYS MCQ solution video, plus full Sec 3 / Sec 4 topic recordings.
Find out more