Mr Khemistry
Suggest Type Questions
Firstly, suggest type questions took up 12/75 (16%) marks in 2018 paper 2 and ~24/80 (30%) marks in paper 3. So we cannot ignore its importance.
 Secondly, most âsuggestâ questions arenât totally novel questions, they are just contextual. Meaning we can look at the question and derive the answer from the information provided.
 In this article, I wish to highlight some ways to think about how to approach such questions. Please refer to the 2018 paper when reading through this document, it will give you some context.
Some simple general questions
- What is the difference between A & B?
- Is this linked to the earlier parts of the qn? What is the direction/flow of the qn?
- Why do we need to do ______? What if we DONâT do _____? What will happen?
- To explain given observations, think about which topic and then narrow down.
- For organic mechanisms, look for similarities with the 6 mechanisms that we have in our syllabus.
- Suggest questions are usually 1-2 marks, try not to vomit out a long answer, it wastes time and doesnât answer the qn.
- How does the change affect the eqm? Are reactants/pdts removed or added?
- To answer qns on suggesting alternative reagents, think abt the properties of the orginal reactant that is important, that defines its role. Then look for the same in the replacement.
- To answer qns about the advantages or disadvantages, think abt what would be an ideal substance/reactant. Usually, it has to do with ease of storage, transportation, non-reactive, not pollutive, not corrosive/dangerous/poisonous or costs. Really depends on the context. E.g. what means a gd fuel (easy to be fully combusted), battery (storage, current), solvent (not reactive with reactants)
- To answer qns how to improve the expt, think abt your aim and assumptions. What would be the ideal expt and what would cause errors?
Suggest Type Questions in 2018 Paper 2 and 3
2018 P2 Q1c(iii) Suggest why, at room temperature, methyl isocyanate is a gas but A is a solid.
CH3NCOÂ Â Â Â Â Â ->Â Â Â Â C6H9N3O3
Methyl isocyanate                  A
Thought process: Given physical properties, we will need to explain this using our knowledge of chemical bonding. A is simply a trimer of methyl isocyanate, so whatâs the difference between the two molecules?
Take note of the earlier parts of the question, usually they will âleadâ you to a certain direction when answering the question. In part (ii), we are told A has no dipole moment, so the higher IMFs is probably not due to pd-pd interactions.
Q2f(ii) Ammonia can be formed from its elements.
N2 (g) + Â H2 (g)Â <-> NH3 (g)Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â âGf0 = -16.6 kJ mol-1
Suggest whether the ratio of [products]/[reactants] at equilibrium for the formation of ammonia at 298K will be less than, equal to or greater than 1. Give a reason for your answer.
Question to ask yourself:
What did part (i) ask about? Is it a clue to how we can answer part (ii)?
Given the negative Gibbs free value, what can you tell about the equilibrium position?
What does the equilibrium position tell you about the ratio of the amount of products vs the amount of reactants?
Standard questions commonly posed as suggest type questions
P2 Q4 (b)(ii) Methylbenzene reacts with fuming sulfuric acid, H2S2O7, to form a mixture of three isomers, G, H and J, in equilibrium.
Suggest why there is a lower concentration of G than of J in the equilibrium mixture.
Qn to ask: Whatâs the difference between G and H/J?
How might this difference hinder the electrophilic attack? (since it is formed in lower conc)
c(iii) K also undergoes a reaction with fuming sulfuric acid.
Suggest the order of reactivity of benzene, methylbenzene and K with fuming sulfuric acid. Explain your answer.
Qn to ask: Order of reactivity depends on whether the substituent group is activating or deactivating. Think about how the substituents increase/decrease the electron density on the benzene ring.
Is âCOCH3 activating or deactivating? In all fairness, this is really a very standard qn.
The importance of reading and underlining key ideas in the question stem…
âWhen the external voltage is increased beyond Ecell, current will flow and a chemical reaction takes place.â
AgCl + e– <-> Cl– + Ag          E0 = -0.22V
O2 + 4H+ + 4e– <-> 2H2OÂ Â Â Â E0 = +1.23V
Qn 5a(i) Suggest why there is a flow of electrons when the external voltage is +1.45V.
Qn to ask: E0cell is exactly 1.45V and since the question stem stated that the current will only flow when external voltage is greater than 1.45V. What does this tell us about the Ecell?
Under what kind of conditions will the EÂcell drop?
(vi)Â Suggest why the water sample is stirred constantly during the measurement.
Qn: What do we want to measure in this electrolysis?
What would happen if we do NOT stir the water sample constantly? Can this idea be applied to other electrolysis/galvanic cell?
(c)(iii) Suggest why the actual value for the pressure recorded in vessel Y was slightly different from the value calculated by this method. Assume oxygen gas behaves as an ideal gas under these conditions.
Qn:Â Whatâs the difference between vessel X and Y?
The question did not specify whether the pressure is more or less in vessel Y so we can either explain it is lower or higher.
We cannot say due to IMF (which is what we do normally) as qn already assumes oxygen behaves ideally.
If explaining it is lower: think in terms how there could be less gaseous oxygen molecules
If explaining it is higher: think maybe how other dissolved gases in water might have escaped.
Can this be applied to other scenarios?
Paper 3
Q1e(ii) In some circumstances, double bonds will undergo a nucleophilic addition reaction. Suggest reasons to explain Fig. 1.2.
Suggest reasons to explain Fig 1.2. Use the concepts of electronegativity, electronic and steric effects, and delocalization in your answer.
Qn to ask: why doesnât 1,3-butadiene undergo nucleophilic addition with HCN? (same reason why LiAlH4 cannot reduce alkenes) Think about the difference between alkene and carbonyl compounds. Hint: Electronegativity, polarity.
As for why B cannot be formed, but C can be formed: Think in terms of steric and electronic effects, the difference between the attack position.
What is the difference between the C=C in 1,3-butadiene and the C=C in 4-methyl-1-penten-3-one? (Only delocalization hasnât been used)
Q2b(i) HCN can be oxidized to cyanogen, C2N2.
C2N2 (g) + 2H+ (aq) + 2e– <-> 2 HCN (aq)Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â E0 = + 0.37 V
Suggest a suitable oxidant to oxidise HCN to C2N2 in acidic solution, using the Data Booklet. Write an equation for the reaction and calculate the E0cell.
Note: Use of Data Booklet means you need to quote data from it.
Qn: If the above half equation is the oxidation half cell, what must be the E0 of the reduction half cell in order to have a spontaneous reaction?
(c) (ii) Suggest why the units of k2 are s-1, despite its rate-determining step being a bimolecular reaction.
Qn: What is the difference between reaction 2 and 3? In order to have units of rate constant as s-1, what must be the total units of the reactants? (hint: think about H2O)
(e) Cyanogen bromide, BrCN, undergoes addition reactions with alkenes. With propene, isomer D is produced rather than isomer E.
Suggest a mechanism for this reaction and use it to explain the preferential production of isomer D.
Qn: Think about which portion of BrCN will get the partial positive charge. Which intermediate carbocation formed will be more stable?
Important exam skill alert!
3c(ii) The addition of NH3(aq) to a solution containing Cu2+(aq) produces a deep blue solution. This solution changes from deep blue to purple when ethane-1,2-diamine, H2NCH2CH2NH2, is added.
Suggest an explanation for this observation and write an equation for the reaction occurring. [The formula of ethane-1,2-diamine can be shortened to en in the formulae and equations of your answer.]
Qn: Change of colour is due to change of ligands, so you need to state en is the stronger ligand. This qn requires an eqn and is only 2 marks hence thereâs no need to explain using âE and wavelength etc.
Usually when the qn wants you to account for the colour, it is about 3 marks. (eg. Qn 5a(i))
Thus an important skill is also to know how much to write and is all the details required. Time is precious, donât regurgitate everything you know about the topic unless required.
Is this a novel qn? Not really, but itâs a âsuggestâ qn as you are not required to remember the ligandsâ strength.
Section B
Q4d(v) The entropy change for the exothermic oxidation of powdered charcoal (carbon) and tetranitratoethane is large and positive. Suggest two reasons why the entropy change for the reaction is large and positive. Explain your answer.
Thought process: We are again presented with observation in this suggest type questions and asked to explain it using our content knowledge.
This is very common and forms the bulk of âsuggestâ type of questions. The context is novel but the concept is not. Usually an analogous example can be found in our syllabus or in the question context.
So we will need to explain two parts, why entropy is large and why itâs positive. Part iv requires us to write the equation so that we can see how the entropy has changed. How many ways are there to increase entropy? This is an easy qn.
Q5b(i) When a solution of sodium vanadate (V) is gradually acidified, the colour changes from colourless to orange to red, and finally to a yellow solution which contains the ion VO2+.
The standard reduction potentials, E0, for the electrode reactions VO3–/VO2+ and VO2+/VO2+ are both +1.00 V.
Suggest how the oxidising abilities of VO3– and VO2+ will change as pH increases, and hence suggest which will be the more powerful oxidant at pH 7. Explain your answer.
Qn: [H+] DECREASES as pH increases. How will that affect the two equilibriums? For oxidising power, is it better to have a lower or higher E0?
Write out the two eqms to see clearly, since the E0 for both eqms is the same, you will need to differentiate which eqm is more affected by a change in [H+].
Parting words…
Hopefully, you now have a good understanding of suggest type questions and how to approach them.
If you’ve found this article useful, feel free to share it with your friends using the share buttons below.
Back to Home of Top Chemistry Tuition